Is the Push Stick an Overpriced Woodworking Tool?
When discussing the indispensable tools of woodworking, push sticks take center stage. However, is the push stick truly an overpriced accessory? This article explores the merits and drawbacks, questioning its necessity and cost-effectiveness.
The Utility of Push Sticks
Consider the humble push stick. Often left unused, these tools are scattered across saw benches, their purpose seemingly obvious. They serve a critical role in preventing fingers from entering the saw blade during cuts, ensuring safety.
If you've ever worked with wood, you’ve likely encountered scraps that are too wide for the blade to move freely. In such cases, a push stick becomes invaluable. By guiding the piece through the saw, you ensure that the cut is clean and precise. Using your fingers would be hazardous, so why not rely on a push stick?
A Practical Approach to Scrap Clearance
When tasked with clearing small offcuts, many woodworkers turn to the piece they just cut. This method is efficient and ensures that the bulk of the scrap is moved from the saw area. If the offcut is substantial, a push stick can be strategically used for that purpose as well. These small accessories are left on the saw bench for just such occasions, making them readily available.
When dealing with wider pieces, push sticks can be used effectively. Pushing the material through near or in the path of the blade ensures a cleaner and safer cut. This is particularly useful for thicker or more awkwardly shaped pieces.
The Case Against Other Tools: Feather Boards
While push sticks are universally accepted, feather boards are often seen as unnecessary. Similar to push sticks, feather boards are designed to stabilize the workpiece during planing. However, their benefits can be achieved in more versatile and cost-effective ways.
For instance, using a combination of clamps and straight edges can effectively hold the wood in place without the need for a dedicated feather board. This approach is far less time-consuming and reduces the clutter of extra equipment on your workbench.
The Cost-Benefit Analysis
When you consider the cost of a push stick versus a programmable miter saw or a band saw, the cost-to-benefit ratio begins to look quite different. While a set of push sticks might run you a few dollars, the same investment in more advanced tools can provide greater flexibility and productivity.
Making the case that wrist guards and push sticks are the only necessary tools is a bold one. After all, over the years, proprietary tools from brands like Festool have gained popularity for their innovative features. However, many of these features can be replicated with simpler and cheaper alternatives.
The Brand-Specific Considerations
The rise of brands like Stylus Licensee has certainly stirred up the woodworking communities. Some, like Keith's shorts, have become household names in the trade. While it’s natural to keep up with the latest innovations, it’s also important to critically evaluate their necessity.
Many tools from Festool, for example, have become synonymous with quality. However, the rising costs of these tools have led some to question their value. Are they worth the investment, especially when cheaper options can meet your needs?
Conclusion
Is the push stick an overpriced woodworking tool? This article argues that while push sticks are essential for safety, their cost-effectiveness varies depending on the woodworking needs and preferences. In many cases, using push sticks alongside simpler, more versatile tools can offer a more practical and budget-friendly solution.
Ultimately, the choice of tools comes down to individual needs and the specific requirements of your woodworking projects. Whether you opt for push sticks, feather boards, or advanced saws, the key is finding the tools that help you work safely and efficiently without overextending your budget.