Why People Shovel Their Sidewalks for Safety and Accessibility

Shoveling sidewalks is a common winter practice aimed at promoting safety and accessibility. Here are some key reasons why people engage in this activity and the benefits it brings to communities and individuals.

Preventing Accidents

One of the primary motivations for shoveling sidewalks is to prevent accidents. Snow and ice can create hazardous and slippery surfaces, increasing the risk of slips and falls for pedestrians. According to the National Safety Council, slip and fall injuries are a leading cause of accidental injuries in the United States. By clearing snow and ice, shoveling helps to mitigate this hazard, ensuring a safer environment for everyone.

Ensuring Accessibility

Clearing sidewalks is also crucial for ensuring that all individuals can navigate safely, including those with disabilities, parents with strollers, and the elderly. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), individuals with disabilities are particularly at risk during winter weather due to their mobility challenges. By keeping sidewalks clear, shoveling promotes accessibility, making it easier for everyone to move about without the risk of slips or falls.

Legal Obligations and Civic Duties

Another reason people shovel their sidewalks is due to legal obligations. Many areas have local laws requiring property owners to clear snow from sidewalks adjoining their property. Failure to do so can result in fines or legal liability for accidents. In addition, shoveling sidewalks is often seen as a civic duty, contributing to the overall safety and well-being of the neighborhood. This action not only protects individuals but also strengthens the community's resilience and cooperation.

Aesthetic Reasons

Clear sidewalks also have aesthetic benefits, enhancing the overall appearance of a community. A tidy and well-maintained sidewalk not only looks neater and more welcoming but also promotes a sense of pride and investment in the neighborhood. This can lead to increased property values and a more positive community atmosphere.

Facilitating Transportation

Shoveling sidewalks is also crucial for facilitating transportation during winter weather. For those who walk, bike, or use public transportation, clear sidewalks are essential for maintaining mobility. According to the Urban Land Institute, safe and accessible sidewalks are a critical component of urban design, supporting walkability and reducing the reliance on motorized transportation.

The Counter-Narrative: Why Shoveling Sidewalks Might Not Be Worth the Effort

While many argue that shoveling sidewalks is essential, others believe that it is a waste of effort. Here are some points that support this counter-argument:

Back Injuries and Shoveling Techniques

Shoveling snow requires proper techniques to prevent back injuries. According to the Orthopedic Institute, improper shoveling techniques can lead to injuries and even exacerbate existing conditions. People who do not know how to shovel correctly often end up damaging their backs, defeating the purpose of trying to prevent injury from icy conditions.

Significant Snow Buildup Persistence

Even after shoveling, snow and ice can persist. Many people use spades or plastic shovels that are ineffective at removing ice, leaving behind a dangerous surface. According to studies, ice left on sidewalks can become more challenging to remove, especially if there is another snowfall.

Environmental Concerns with Salt Usage

Attempting to mitigate ice formation with salt can have negative environmental impacts. Salt must be shipped by truck and is sourced through mining, contributing to pollution. According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), salt usage can also harm local plant and animal life, leading to environmental degradation.

Slip Risks During Shoveling

Shoveling can be risky, especially for those who are not accustomed to physical exertion. According to research published in the Journal of Safety Research, there is a higher risk of slipping while shoveling a driveway than walking on a sidewalk. This higher risk can outweigh the benefits of improved sidewalk accessibility.

Natural Snow Creation of Ice-Free Environments

Natural snow can often provide protection against ice. Snow can act as a natural insulator, protecting surfaces from freezing. As snow accumulates, it can create a safer environment by reducing ice formation, as noted by snowboarding experts who observe ski slopes.

In conclusion, while shoveling sidewalks can be beneficial, it is not always the most effective or necessary action. For those living in areas with challenging winter weather, it is essential to weigh the benefits and risks and find the best solutions for their specific circumstances.