The Bachelor's Perspective on Fantasy Literature and Christian Readership
Recently, a provocative comment was made suggesting that Christians should avoid certain books, specifically the 'Lord of the Rings', 'The Hobbit', 'Harry Potter', and 'The Wheel of Time'. I would like to express my own thoughts on this topic, particularly focusing on the impact of fantasy literature for Christian readers.
Is This Comment Valid?
While the comment may contain a technical grammatical error ('The Lord of the Rings' rather than 'Lord of the Rings'), the real issue lies in the conclusion that Christians should avoid these books. From my perspective, and without involving myself in moral or spiritual judgment, this is clearly a matter for individual conscience. However, my personal view is that any prohibition on reading such books is overly restrictive and fails to consider the value in such literature.
The Case Against Over-caoution
First of all, claiming that someone or a group should not read a particular book is a form of arrogance that disrespects everyone's right to make their own choices. Essentially, the author of the comment is implying that they know what is best for Christians, which is a form of over-reaching opinion and not helpful at all. No one has the right to tell others what to read or not to read, especially not based on their own personal beliefs or preferences.
The Importance of Context
Regarding the content of these books, I genuinely enjoy good science fiction and fantasy literature. Growing up, I devoured The Lord of the Rings, and was captivated by its blend of historical setting and mythological elements. J.R.R. Tolkien, the masterful author, was a Catholic who lost his parents at a young age and was later raised by Father Francis Morgan, a Catholic priest. His stories are more than just imaginative tales; they reflect moral and ethical values that resonate with many. The moral that rules are best made after doing one’s homework is fundamentally sound and applicable here. Reading these books doesn't necessarily mean everyone will adopt the same beliefs, but it does open up the possibility of a deeper understanding and appreciation of the human condition.
Comparing Harry Potter and The Lord of the Rings
While I enjoy Tolkien's works, I am less convinced by another author, J.K. Rowling, whose Harry Potter series takes a different approach. Harry Potter, despite its popularity, is often criticized for its heavy focus on magic and potentially dangerous magical elements. The series is too close to the biblical description of demons and might not align with some Christian values. However, this is a matter of personal judgment and certainly not a universal rule. Focusing on the individual’s worldview and the impact of such works on their beliefs is important.
The Broader Question of Rules and Restrictions
Furthermore, if fantasy books are deemed off-limits, where does that leave the Bible? The Bible itself is filled with mythical and supernatural elements, yet it is widely accepted and studied. If we are to follow a strict reading ban, then the Bible too should face scrutiny. The rationality of such exclusions brings into question whether the ban on these fantasy books is more about personal comfort than genuine values. Allowing open reading and open discussion can help individuals make informed choices without feeling pressured by external restrictions.
My Final Thoughts
In conclusion, I fundamentally disagree with the notion that Christians should avoid reading certain fantasy books. It's important to respect individual choices and personal judgments. Books like 'The Lord of the Rings' offer a rich and transformative reading experience that can deepen one's spiritual understanding. Let us encourage open dialogue and critical thinking rather than restrictive judgments. As the saying goes, 'rules are best made after doing one's homework,' and in this case, that homework involves understanding the value of diverse literature for spiritual and intellectual growth.