The Unbelievable Costs of Filling an Above-Ground Pool with Dirt

Many pool enthusiasts are curious about the process and cost of filling an above-ground pool with dirt. However, it turns out, the task is much more complicated than just scooping up soil and pouring it in. There are numerous factors and considerations that make this project far more complex and costly.

Local Regulations and Requirements

Before embarking on the project, you'll need to contact your local building and zoning department to understand their specific requirements. Many areas mandate that the floor of the pool must be punched through to ensure that the soil can percolate, allowing proper drainage. Some areas may also require the walls of the pool to be knocked down. Vinyl pools may be exempt from this requirement, but it depends on the local regulations. Ignoring these regulations can result in hefty fines or even legal action.

The Amount of Fill Dirt Needed

Assuming you can proceed with the project, you'll need to calculate the amount of fill dirt required. This involves determining the cubic volume of the pool, which is usually expressed in cubic yards. For a small to medium-sized pool, it's estimated that you will need around 10 truckloads of fill dirt. However, the exact amount will depend on the size and shape of your pool.

Cost of Labor and Materials

Estimating the cost of filling an above-ground pool with dirt is not straightforward. It requires a bit of math and a clear understanding of the factors involved:

The Size of the Pool: The square footage of the pool will affect the amount of dirt needed and the labor required to move it. DIY vs. Contractor: You can do it yourself, but hiring a contractor might be more efficient and cost-effective. Keep in mind that contractors often have the necessary equipment and experience to handle this task. Pre-existing Structures: If you have a pump, fence, or other structures in place, these can add additional costs. These items may be worth money if you remove them and dispose of or sell them. Types of Soil: Not all soil is created equal. Using specialized filling dirt (often called "Phil Dirt"), which is free from harmful materials like clay or sand, can be more expensive but is recommended for construction. Topsoil or Black Dirt: After filling with the desired soil, adding a layer of topsoil or black dirt on top can improve the quality of the ground and make the area more suitable for planting or other uses. Labor and Equipment: Renting a front-end loader or using wheelbarrows and shovels can significantly impact the cost. Labor costs are also a critical factor and can vary depending on the location and availability of workers. Additional Costs: Don't forget about the cost of lunch and any other associated expenses.

While DIY projects can save money, they also require time and expertise. Contractors can provide valuable services, but their cost must be balanced against the convenience and potential savings.

Potential Risks and Considerations

There are several risks and considerations to keep in mind:

Structural Integrity: Filling an above-ground pool with dirt may compromise its structural integrity. The weight of the dirt can cause the pool walls to collapse, leading to further costs to rebuild or repair the structure. Drainage: Proper drainage is essential for a pool. Ensuring that the soil can percolate and drain correctly will prevent water accumulation and potential damage to the pool. Location and Local Regulations: The cost of filling with dirt can vary significantly depending on your location, including the price of labor and dirt. It's crucial to understand the local regulations and requirements to avoid unexpected expenses.

While the idea of filling an above-ground pool with dirt seems intriguing, it's not a simple or cost-effective solution. It's important to weigh the potential benefits against the numerous risks and costs involved. If you're serious about this plan, it's best to consult with professionals who can provide reliable estimates and guidance.